Several new, newer or less regular players, or players who haven't played together before much or at all, so I will suggest line ups after 4 pm tomorrow. I've added the team captain poll. I've included everyone who has played at least 12 games in the current 6 month period or 40 games over the past 3 years.
For Team 1, Gerard and Sven have 1 vote each, so the player who has played more games in the current 6 month period can be captain. That would be Gerard with 19 games (Sven with 13). No one on Team 2 has any votes, so the player with the most number of games in the current 6 month period can be captain. That would be Shamir with 19 games.